When people hear the phrase dividend stocks, they often think of one thing: the highest yield possible. Personally, I think that’s one of the biggest mistakes TFSA investors can make. If all I wanted was the biggest dividend cheque today, this list would look very different. But that’s not how I build my own watchlist, and it’s not how I’d build a TFSA portfolio. The way I see it, a TFSA should hold businesses that have the potential to grow for years while rewarding shareholders along the way.
A reliable dividend is important, but so is earnings growth, financial strength, and the ability to keep increasing that dividend over time. I also believe diversification matters. I don’t want every company in my TFSA relying on the same economic driver. That’s why this list spans several industries instead of loading up on banks, pipelines, or utilities. These aren’t necessarily the highest-yielding dividend stocks on the TSX. They’re the companies I’d feel comfortable owning for the long haul.
#5 ATCO Ltd. (ACO-X.TO)
Approximate Share Price: $78 CAD
Market Capitalization: $7.9 billion CAD
Dividend Yield: 2.6%
Industry: Utilities & Infrastructure
Why It Made My List
ATCO rarely gets the attention it deserves. While many investors focus on the larger Canadian utilities, I continue coming back to ATCO because of the stability of its businesses. Electricity, natural gas infrastructure, industrial services, and modular structures aren’t exciting industries, but they produce dependable cash flows. With governments continuing to invest in infrastructure, electrical grids, and energy reliability, I think companies like ATCO remain well positioned for the years ahead.
What I Like
One thing I really like is the consistency. ATCO has built its reputation by operating businesses that people rely on every single day. That creates recurring revenue, predictable cash flow, and a solid foundation for paying dividends. Management has also demonstrated discipline over many years. Rather than chasing risky expansion, they’ve generally focused on growing the business steadily while maintaining a healthy balance sheet. That’s exactly the kind of business I don’t mind holding through different market cycles.
One Thing I’d Watch
Utility businesses require significant capital spending. Higher interest rates can increase financing costs, so I’d continue watching how borrowing expenses affect future growth projects.
Would I Buy Today?
I’d happily own ATCO as part of a diversified TFSA. It probably won’t be my fastest-growing investment, but I appreciate the stability it brings to a long-term portfolio.
#4 Exchange Income Corporation (EIF.TO)
Approximate Share Price: $125 CAD
Market Capitalization: $7 billion CAD
Dividend Yield: 2.2%
Industry: Aerospace & Industrial Services
Why It Made My List
Exchange Income has quietly become one of Canada’s most interesting dividend companies. Its business spans regional aviation, aerospace services, manufacturing, and essential transportation—industries that continue benefiting from strong demand and long-term infrastructure spending. I also like that the company isn’t dependent on a single customer or industry.
What I Like
The monthly dividend certainly catches people’s attention, but that’s actually not the main reason I like the company. It’s the diversified business model. Exchange Income has built a portfolio of businesses that generate recurring cash flow while continuing to acquire complementary companies over time. That strategy has helped it grow earnings while supporting its dividend. Management has shown they’re willing to reinvest in growth without sacrificing financial discipline.
One Thing I’d Watch
Acquisitions have played an important role in the company’s growth. I’d continue watching how successfully management integrates future acquisitions without taking on excessive debt.
Would I Buy Today?
Personally, I’d have no problem owning Exchange Income for years. It’s one of those businesses that I think many Canadian investors overlook.
#3 MTY Food Group (MTY)
Approximate Share Price: $33 CAD
Market Capitalization: $765 million CAD
Dividend Yield: 4.4%
Industry: Restaurant Franchising
Why It Made My List
Consumer spending has been under pressure over the past couple of years, but that’s exactly why MTY continues to interest me. Unlike traditional restaurant operators, MTY primarily operates a franchise model, which tends to generate attractive cash flow while requiring less capital than owning every location outright. As interest rates gradually normalize, I think consumer confidence could improve, providing another tailwind for restaurant spending.
What I Like
The asset-light business model stands out. Franchise fees generate recurring revenue while reducing many of the operating risks faced by restaurant owners. MTY has also built an impressive portfolio of restaurant brands through acquisitions over many years. It’s not a flashy company, but sometimes those are the businesses that quietly reward patient investors.
One Thing I’d Watch
Consumer spending remains the biggest variable. If Canadians continue cutting discretionary spending, restaurant traffic could remain under pressure longer than expected.
Would I Buy Today?
I’d be comfortable slowly building a position over time. I like the long-term business more than I’m worried about short-term consumer trends.
#2 Canadian Tire Corporation (CTC-A.TO)
Approximate Share Price: $201 CAD
Market Capitalization: $10 billion CAD
Dividend Yield: 3.6%
Industry: Retail & Financial Services
Why It Made My List
I think many investors underestimate Canadian Tire. Most people simply see a retailer. I see a company with iconic Canadian brands, valuable real estate, an established loyalty program, and a financial services business that adds another source of earnings. As borrowing costs gradually ease and consumer spending improves, Canadian Tire could benefit from multiple angles.
What I Like
Canadian Tire has built something that’s incredibly difficult to replicate. Its brand recognition, nationwide footprint, and customer loyalty create a competitive advantage that has taken decades to establish. The company also generates meaningful cash flow while continuing to reward shareholders through dividends. That’s a combination I always appreciate.
One Thing I’d Watch
Retail can be unpredictable. If consumer spending weakens further, discretionary purchases could slow, putting pressure on earnings growth.
Would I Buy Today?
I like Canadian Tire for investors willing to think beyond the next quarter. I’d be comfortable owning it in a diversified TFSA for the long term.
#1 Bank of Nova Scotia (BNS.TO)
Approximate Share Price: $122 CAD
Market Capitalization: $149 billion CAD
Dividend Yield: 3.7%
Industry: Banking
Why It Made My List
Scotiabank takes the top spot because I think the market may still be underestimating its long-term potential. The bank has spent the past few years reshaping parts of its international business while continuing to generate strong earnings and maintain one of the more attractive dividend yields among Canada’s major banks. If interest rates continue moving lower, loan demand could gradually improve while credit concerns become less of a headwind.
What I Like
Canadian banks have proven remarkably resilient over decades. Scotiabank combines that stability with a strong dividend history and a management team that’s actively refining the business rather than standing still. The dividend remains well supported by earnings, and I think the bank still has room to grow over time. For long-term TFSA investors, that’s exactly the type of combination I’m looking for.
One Thing I’d Watch
Credit quality will remain important. If the Canadian economy slows more than expected, higher loan losses could temporarily weigh on earnings. It’s something I’ll continue watching, but not something that changes my long-term view today.
Would I Buy Today?
Yes. If I were adding another Canadian bank to my TFSA today, Scotiabank would be near the top of my list. I’d be perfectly comfortable holding it for the next decade rather than worrying about what happens over the next few months.
Final Thoughts
When I look at this list, one theme stands out. These aren’t simply high-yield dividend stocks. They’re businesses that I believe have the potential to continue growing while paying shareholders along the way. That’s an important distinction. A TFSA is one of the most powerful investing accounts Canadians have, and I don’t want to fill mine with companies chosen solely because they offer the biggest dividend today.
I’d rather own businesses with durable competitive advantages, healthy balance sheets, and management teams that can continue creating value over many years. Over the next year, I’ll be paying close attention to interest rates, consumer spending, infrastructure investment, and corporate earnings. Those trends will likely have a meaningful impact on each of these companies, even though they operate in very different industries.
Ready to start investing? Click the Qtrade banner below to learn more and open a Qtrade Direct Investing account.
