A good Canadian business is not automatically an undervalued stock, and a low multiple can be a warning rather than an opportunity. I’m looking for a gap between the market’s expectations and what the business can reasonably earn or distribute through the cycle. That requires looking beyond the share price to assets, cash generation, balance-sheet strength and risks. The five TSX names below offer different value cases, not interchangeable bargains.
This September 29, 2026 shortlist counts down five candidates from #5 to #1. The order is a qualitative judgment of the valuation case, business quality, catalysts and downside risk, not a mathematical score or a promise of returns. Shopify’s growth remains impressive, but a September 28 price-to-free-cash-flow multiple of about 79.5 does not establish a clear value case without stronger assumptions. Fairfax offers a more defensible alternative alongside Magna, Power, CNQ and Scotiabank.
Ready to start investing? Click the Qtrade banner below to learn more and open a Qtrade Direct Investing account.
How I Judge Undervaluation
I compare valuation with peers and a business’s own earning power, then test whether a catalyst could narrow the gap. Asset value, sustainable earnings and cash flow matter more than an isolated low P/E; a discount may be deserved when leverage, cyclicality or execution risks are high. Forward multiples below are September 29, 2026 estimates from S&P Global data presented by Stock Analysis, not reported earnings or fair-value targets. Company results generally cover Q2 ended June 30; Scotiabank’s fiscal Q3 ended July 31, and Power’s asset-value comparison uses a separately dated price.
#5 – Magna International Inc. (TSX: MG)
Why Now
Magna’s value case depends on a credible margin recovery, not simply the growth of electric vehicles. September 29 valuation data showed a forward P/E of about 8.8, compared with a much higher trailing multiple. That gap reflects expectations of improved earnings, so it is an opportunity only if those estimates prove achievable. Its exposure to several vehicle technologies is useful, but customer production cuts and contract economics still matter.
The Moat
Magna isn’t just a parts supplier — it’s a full-service mobility platform. Its ability to design, engineer, and manufacture entire vehicle systems gives it deep integration with OEMs. That scale and diversification across geographies and customers create a significant barrier to entry.
Financial Snapshot
In Q2 2026, Magna reported US$10.98 billion of sales and a 6.2% adjusted EBIT margin, up from 5.5% a year earlier. Management raised its 2026 adjusted EPS outlook to US$6.70–US$7.30; that is guidance, not a delivered result. The reported US$617 million of quarterly free cash flow is encouraging, but first-half cash generation also benefited from customer recoveries on cancelled programs. I would watch repeatable margin improvement rather than assume every cash-flow benefit will recur.
One Key Risk
Auto demand is cyclical. If global economic conditions weaken or EV adoption slows, Magna’s volumes — and margins — could come under pressure again.
#4 – Power Corporation of Canada (TSX: POW)
Why Now
Power’s case is an asset-value discount rather than a simple earnings-multiple bargain. Its June 30, 2026 adjusted net asset value was C$112.94 per share, while the September 25 closing price was C$94.28—roughly 16.5% below that older asset-value reference. These are different dates, so this is not a September mark-to-market NAV calculation. The opportunity depends on underlying asset performance and capital allocation; a holding-company discount can remain structural.
The Moat
The strength here is structure. Through holdings like Great-West Lifeco and IGM Financial, Power Corp has a diversified stream of earnings tied to long-term capital allocation businesses. These are sticky, recurring revenue models that perform well over time.
Financial Snapshot
Power reported C$690 million of Q2 2026 net earnings attributable to participating shareholders, down from C$772 million a year earlier. Holding-company cash was C$2.196 billion at June 30, providing flexibility without implying that subsidiary cash is freely available to the parent. Its insurance and wealth-management holdings remain central to the thesis. I would monitor those businesses and the discount together rather than rely on an undated dividend yield or claim uninterrupted earnings growth.
One Key Risk
Conglomerate discounts can persist longer than expected. Even with solid underlying businesses, the market may continue to undervalue the structure.
#3 – Canadian Natural Resources Limited (TSX: CNQ)
Why Now
CNQ’s long-life asset base makes cash generation and reinvestment needs more useful than a short-term stock-price target. September 29 data showed about 12.0 times trailing earnings and 12.5 times forward estimated earnings. Those multiples provide a starting point for a value case, not proof: high commodity earnings can make an energy stock look deceptively cheap. I would ask whether the cash return remains attractive at less favourable oil and gas prices.
The Moat
Scale and efficiency. CNQ operates some of the lowest-decline, longest-life assets in the oil sands. That allows for predictable production and lower reinvestment costs compared to peers — a huge advantage in volatile commodity markets.
Financial Snapshot
In Q2 2026, CNQ reported C$6.866 billion of adjusted funds flow and C$14.5 billion of net debt, both company-defined measures. Management raised its 2026 production outlook to 1.637–1.682 million barrels of oil equivalent per day; that remains guidance. Its C$2.975 billion quarterly free-cash-flow measure is after net capital spending, abandonment costs and dividends, so it should not be compared casually with another company’s free cash flow. The value thesis requires disciplined spending and debt management through the commodity cycle.
One Key Risk
Commodity exposure. A sharp drop in oil prices would directly impact cash flow and investor sentiment, even for a best-in-class operator like CNQ.
#2 – Fairfax Financial Holdings Limited (TSX: FFH)
Why Now
Fairfax offers a more defensible value case than paying a growth premium and calling it cheap. September 29 valuation data showed about 7.6 times trailing earnings and 8.1 times forward estimated earnings. Its underwriting results and liquidity provide business evidence alongside that multiple. The discount could be attractive if earnings quality holds, but investment gains can flatter reported profit and must be separated from recurring operating performance.
The Moat
Fairfax combines property-and-casualty insurance operations with an investment portfolio. Underwriting discipline matters because insurance float is valuable only when the obligations behind it are managed sensibly. Its international operations and investment flexibility provide several routes to build value. That structure also makes capital allocation and management judgment central to the investment case.
Financial Snapshot
Fairfax’s Q2 2026 results reported a 93.1% undiscounted combined ratio and US$458.6 million of underwriting profit. Holding-company cash and marketable securities were US$2.3 billion, with a further US$2 billion undrawn credit facility. Net earnings included significant investment gains, notably from the Poseidon sale, so the headline P/E is not a clean measure of recurring underwriting income. These U.S.-dollar figures should not be mixed with the Canadian-dollar stock quote.
One Key Risk
Catastrophe losses, weaker insurance pricing and investment-market swings can all change the earnings picture. Fairfax’s debt-to-capital ratio excluding non-insurance operations rose to 28% at June 30 from 26.2% at year-end, so balance-sheet risk still deserves attention. A low multiple does not remove the possibility of underwriting mistakes or poor capital allocation. I would monitor recurring insurance performance rather than assume investment gains will repeat.
#1 – Bank of Nova Scotia (TSX: BNS)
Why Now
Scotiabank is a relative recovery case rather than an obvious deep-value bank at any price. September 29 forward P/E estimates were about 14.2 for BNS versus 16.4 for RBC, using the same data provider. That discount may reflect weaker profitability and execution risks, so it becomes an opportunity only if the earnings improvement is durable. The Big Five bank comparison helps put those business differences in context.
The Moat
Like all Canadian banks, Scotiabank benefits from an oligopolistic domestic market with high barriers to entry. Its international footprint — particularly in Latin America — adds growth potential that most peers lack.
Financial Snapshot
For fiscal Q3 ended July 31, 2026, Scotiabank reported a 13.1% CET1 capital ratio and 14.2% adjusted return on equity in its quarterly results. It repurchased 8.6 million shares during the quarter. Those results support the recovery thesis but do not prove a specific fair value, and the reporting period differs from the June 30 quarters used above. I would monitor credit losses, capital strength and recurring profitability rather than rely on a stale yield or an earnings-beat headline.
One Key Risk
Execution risk in international markets. Economic instability or currency fluctuations in key regions could impact earnings more than domestically focused peers.
Final Thoughts
Undervalued Canadian stocks require patience and a clear explanation of what the market may be overlooking. These five cases depend on different drivers, from margin recovery to asset discounts and underwriting performance. That is why I would not buy them all simply because their multiples look lower than a popular growth stock’s. The risks behind the discount deserve as much attention as the catalyst.
Magna is a margin-recovery case, Power an asset-discount case, CNQ a cyclical cash-generation case, Fairfax an insurance-and-capital-allocation case, and Scotiabank a relative bank-recovery case. None comes with a guaranteed rerating. Compare the valuation with what each business can earn through less favourable conditions, then decide which uncertainty you are prepared to own. A good thesis should still make sense without relying on an analyst target.
Over the next 12 months, focus on three things:
- Interest rate direction and its impact on financials and valuations
- Commodity stability, especially in energy
- Earnings quality, not just growth
Cheap and undervalued are not the same thing. A discount may narrow when results improve, or persist because the market correctly recognizes a structural risk. I would track the evidence supporting each case and reassess if it weakens. Treat this dated shortlist as a starting point for research, not a promise that all five stocks will outperform.
Thanks for reading, please feel free to leave a comment and subscribe to our blog.
Ready to start investing? Click the Qtrade banner below to learn more and open a Qtrade Direct Investing account.
Pingback: Top 5 ESG Stocks in Canada for 2026: Sustainable Investing Picks That Outperform - Outsider Trading