Top 5 Investing Mistakes Canadians Should Fix Before 2027

We’re getting close to the end of 2026, and I’ve been thinking about something that doesn’t get nearly enough attention when we talk about investing. Everybody wants to know which stocks will outperform next year. Which sectors are about to take off? Is there another AI company waiting to explode? Should we be buying more Canadian banks, energy stocks, or technology? Those are interesting questions. I spend plenty of time thinking about them myself.

But here’s another question worth asking: What if improving your returns in 2027 has less to do with finding your next winning stock and more to do with fixing what’s already wrong with your portfolio? I think a lot of investors, myself included at times, spend too much energy looking for opportunities and not enough examining the decisions they’ve already made. With another year approaching, I’ve identified five mistakes worth addressing before January. These aren’t necessarily beginner mistakes, either. Even experienced investors can fall into them.

Let’s count them down.

#5 — Holding Investments You Wouldn’t Buy Again Today

This one can be surprisingly difficult to admit. Maybe you bought a stock because its earnings were growing rapidly. Perhaps you expected interest rates to fall, commodity prices to recover, or a new product to become successful. Fast-forward a year, and the story has changed.

The company’s margins are shrinking. Its debt is increasing. Management keeps pushing profitability further into the future. Yet the shares are still sitting in your portfolio. Why? Sometimes we’re waiting to break even. Other times we’ve become attached to the original investment idea.

But the market doesn’t care what we originally paid for something.

Here’s a question I like asking when reviewing a holding: If I had this money sitting in cash today, would I buy this company at its current price, knowing everything I know now? A no doesn’t automatically mean I should sell. Taxes, portfolio balance, and the possibility of a turnaround still matter. But it does mean the investment deserves another look.

What I’d fix before 2027: Review your holdings and write down why you still own each one. If you can’t explain the investment case without referring to your purchase price, it’s probably time for some additional research.

#4 — Confusing a High Dividend Yield With a Good Investment

I understand why Canadian investors love dividends. There’s something satisfying about watching cash arrive in your account without having to sell shares. And when those payments are reinvested, the compounding can become meaningful over time. But I’ve also noticed how easily investors get distracted by unusually high yields. Imagine two companies.

Company A yields 7%, but its earnings are declining and its dividend consumes nearly all its available cash flow. Company B yields 3.5%, generates consistent free cash flow, and has room to increase its dividend. Which one would I rather own for the next decade? Personally, I’d be much more interested in understanding Company B.

A high dividend yield can sometimes be the result of a falling share price rather than a particularly generous business. And if the underlying company isn’t producing enough cash to support its distribution, that attractive yield could disappear. I don’t think every high-yield stock is dangerous. Some businesses operate in mature industries where substantial distributions make sense. The important question is whether the dividend is sustainable.

What I’d fix before 2027: Review your dividend holdings for payout sustainability, debt obligations, and free cash flow. Don’t judge an investment by its yield alone. Look at the total return and the strength of the business supporting it.

#3 — Letting Your Portfolio Become More Concentrated Than You Realize

This is something I think Canadian investors need to pay particular attention to. Our stock market has some excellent companies, especially in financial services, energy, utilities, and natural resources. But that strength can also create a problem. You might own five Canadian bank stocks, two financial-sector ETFs, and a broad Canadian-market ETF.

At first glance, that looks like eight different investments. In reality, you could have a substantial portion of your portfolio exposed to the same economic conditions. Now consider what happens if Canadian consumers weaken, credit losses increase, or the domestic economy slows. Several investments that appeared diversified could struggle together. The same problem exists with technology.

Owning multiple ETFs doesn’t necessarily provide meaningful diversification if they all hold many of the same large technology companies. I’m not suggesting investors should avoid concentrated positions entirely. Some investors deliberately accept concentration because they have strong convictions. But there’s a difference between taking that risk intentionally and discovering it after a market correction.

What I’d fix before 2027: Look through your ETFs and individual stocks. Identify overlapping holdings and calculate your exposure by sector, geography, and major company. Make sure the portfolio you actually own matches the risks you’re comfortable taking.

#2 — Taking Too Much Risk With Money You’ll Need Soon

This mistake becomes particularly important when we’re approaching a new calendar year. Maybe you’re planning to purchase a home in 2027. Perhaps you’re expecting a major expense, approaching retirement, or anticipating a period when your income might be less predictable. Whatever the situation, the question isn’t simply how much your investments could earn.

It’s when you’ll need the money. Imagine having $30,000 invested in stocks that you intend to use for a down payment next summer. If the market falls 25%, that money could temporarily become $22,500. That’s a $7,500 shortfall at exactly the wrong time. The investments might eventually recover. But your home purchase won’t necessarily wait for the market. I think investors sometimes confuse having a long-term mindset with keeping every available dollar invested aggressively. They’re not the same thing.

Money intended for retirement twenty years from now can tolerate very different risks than money needed in eight months. Personally, I would rather give up some potential upside on short-term savings than risk being forced to sell investments during a downturn. That might mean using a high-interest savings account, an appropriate GIC, or another lower-risk option suited to the withdrawal date.

What I’d fix before 2027: Separate your money into short-term and long-term goals. Make sure funds needed within the next year or two aren’t exposed to more market risk than you can reasonably afford.

#1 — Entering 2027 Without an Actual Investment Plan

This is the biggest mistake on my list. Not because every investor needs a complicated spreadsheet or a twenty-page financial plan. Quite the opposite. I think the best investing plans are often surprisingly simple. The problem comes when investors make decisions entirely based on whatever happens to be capturing attention. Technology stocks rally, so they buy technology. Energy prices rise, so they add oil producers. Markets decline, so they stop contributing.

An exciting stock appears on social media, and suddenly they’re considering an investment they knew nothing about the previous morning. I’ve seen how easily investing can become reactive rather than deliberate. And with another year approaching, that’s something worth correcting. Your investment plan should determine your decisions. The latest headline shouldn’t be writing your plan for you. For me, a useful plan answers a handful of straightforward questions.

How much can I consistently invest each month? What am I investing toward? How much risk am I prepared to accept? What would make me sell an investment? And how will I know whether I’m making progress? Consider someone investing $400 monthly. That’s $4,800 annually before any investment returns. It might not sound particularly exciting compared with finding a stock that doubles in value.

But those consistent contributions are real, measurable progress. They don’t depend on guessing which company will become next year’s market favourite. I also think investors should decide ahead of time how they’ll respond when markets decline. It’s easy to claim you’re comfortable with volatility when everything is going up. Watching your portfolio lose 20% is a different experience. Having a plan doesn’t eliminate that discomfort, but it can prevent the discomfort from becoming an expensive decision.

What I’d fix before 2027: Write a simple investment plan outlining your goals, contribution schedule, target allocation, and reasons for selling. Review it periodically rather than rewriting it every time the market changes direction.

Final Thoughts — Make 2027 About Better Decisions

One thing I’ve learned from following businesses and markets is that investing always gives us something new to worry about. Interest rates, inflation, artificial intelligence, commodity prices, consumer spending, and corporate earnings will all influence markets over the coming year. Some opportunities will work out. Others won’t. And no matter how much research we do, we’re going to get certain things wrong. That’s unavoidable.

What isn’t unavoidable is entering another year with a portfolio we haven’t properly reviewed. For Canadians building their first $100,000, these mistakes can be particularly costly. Every unnecessary fee, poorly timed sale, or oversized position can interrupt progress that took months or years to build. But the same lessons matter for investors with much larger portfolios. Before the calendar turns to 2027, I’d encourage you to spend an evening reviewing what you own, why you own it, and whether those investments still fit your goals.

You might discover that everything is working exactly as intended. Or you might find a few things worth changing. Either outcome makes the exercise worthwhile. The best investment you make before 2027 might not be another stock. It might be a better decision about the ones you already own.

Disclaimer: This article is for educational purposes only and does not constitute personalized financial or investment advice. All investments involve risk, and individual circumstances should guide investment decisions.

Leave a Comment

Scroll to Top