10 RRSP Investing Mistakes Canadians Should Avoid

An RRSP can reduce taxable income today, shelter investment growth while the money stays inside the account, and help fund retirement decades down the road. But having one doesn’t automatically mean you’re using it well. Most RRSP conversations seem to happen around tax season. People discuss contribution amounts and refunds. Far fewer talk about what they’re investing in or how they’ll eventually withdraw the money. Those decisions matter just as much. Here are ten mistakes worth reviewing, from everyday habits to the bigger retirement questions.

#10 — Only Thinking About Your RRSP at Tax Time

There’s nothing wrong with contributing before the deadline. The problem is treating RRSP investing as a once-a-year task. For the 2026 tax year, the CRA’s contribution deadline is March 1, 2027. That’s a useful date, but it shouldn’t be your entire investing strategy. Regular contributions spread purchases across market conditions and reduce the need to find a lump sum in February. I’d rather see someone follow a manageable plan throughout the year than scramble for a contribution just to chase a refund.

#9 — Contributing Money and Forgetting to Invest It

An RRSP is an account, not an investment. Putting $5,000 into it doesn’t necessarily mean that $5,000 is working in the market. Your contribution might sit in cash until you select an eligible investment. Cash makes sense for some short-term needs. But unintentionally leaving retirement savings uninvested for years is different. Open your RRSP and check what you actually own. It sounds almost too simple, yet it’s an easy detail to miss.

#8 — Paying Investment Fees Without Knowing What They Cost

Investment fees can look harmless because they’re often shown as small percentages. Consider $50,000 invested in two funds. At a hypothetical annual fee of 1.75%, that’s $875 on the starting balance. At 0.25%, it’s $125. The $750 difference is money that doesn’t remain invested that year. That gap can compound. Cheaper isn’t automatically better; compare investments, risks, and services too. Check the management expense ratios on your funds, along with any advisory, trading, and currency-conversion costs. Know what you’re paying for.

#7 — Mistaking Familiar Canadian Stocks for Diversification

Canadian banks, pipelines, and dividend payers appeal to investors for good reasons. They’re familiar businesses. But holding five Canadian dividend stocks doesn’t necessarily give you five different sources of risk. You may still be heavily exposed to the same economy, sectors, and interest-rate conditions. Ask yourself: if Canada struggles, how much of my portfolio struggles too? Broad Canadian and global ETFs are worth researching as one way to diversify. The goal isn’t to avoid Canadian companies. It’s to avoid relying on only one part of the market.

#6 — Assuming RRSP Withdrawals Work Like TFSA Withdrawals

This is where account rules can become expensive. Ordinary RRSP withdrawals are generally taxable income. Tax withheld at withdrawal isn’t necessarily your final tax bill. Unlike a TFSA, an ordinary RRSP withdrawal doesn’t give you the contribution room back. If you take money out to cover a short-term expense, you may permanently lose that tax-sheltered space. Programs like the Home Buyers’ Plan have exceptions, but their rules don’t apply to everyday withdrawals. Before taking money out, look at both the tax impact and whether you’re giving up room you can’t replace. Our TFSA investing rules explain how the two accounts differ.

#5 — Guessing How Much RRSP Contribution Room You Have

The 2026 annual RRSP dollar limit is $33,810, but that isn’t everyone’s personal contribution allowance. Your room depends on earned income, carry-forward room, pension adjustments, and contributions. It may be much lower. Generally, excess contributions more than $2,000 above your deduction limit can trigger a 1% monthly tax. That $2,000 cushion isn’t extra deductible room to casually use. Before contributing, check your latest CRA notice of assessment and reconcile it with contributions you’ve already made, including workplace or spousal RRSP contributions where applicable. My 2026 RRSP contribution guide provides a closer look at the contribution rules. Personally, I’d rather spend ten minutes checking than spend months sorting out an avoidable overcontribution.

#4 — Treating the Tax Refund as the Whole Reward

I like the tax deduction that comes with an RRSP. Who wouldn’t? But a refund isn’t free investment income. It’s connected to a deduction today, while ordinary withdrawals are generally taxed later. The difference between your tax rate now and the rate when you withdraw can make a big difference. For example, a $10,000 deduction saves roughly $3,000 at a 30% marginal tax rate, versus $2,000 at 20%, assuming the deduction falls entirely within those rates. The CRA lets you carry eligible deductions forward, but delaying has an opportunity cost. Think about the timing of the deduction, not just the size of the refund.

#3 — Automatically Choosing an RRSP Over a TFSA

I’ve never liked the idea that one account is universally better. An RRSP may be especially attractive when your marginal tax rate is relatively high today and lower when you eventually withdraw. A TFSA can make more sense when you expect the opposite, or when tax-free withdrawal flexibility matters. That comparison looks different early in your career than at peak earnings. Benefits and contribution room matter too. Before directing every extra dollar to your RRSP, compare both accounts using the same after-tax savings budget. The best answer may be to use both.

#2 — Taking the Wrong Amount of Risk for Your Timeline

The same ETF can represent different risks to different investors. Someone with 25 years before retirement may be able to tolerate market declines that would be much harder for someone planning to withdraw the money next year. On the other hand, hiding everything in low-growth investments for decades can create a different problem: not accumulating enough. The mistake is ignoring when you’ll need the money. Review your mix of stocks, bonds, GICs, and cash against your timeline and ability to handle losses. Don’t build a portfolio that only works when markets are calm.

#1 — Building an RRSP Without Planning How to Withdraw It

This is the mistake I would put first, although reasonable investors could rank these differently. We spend years asking how to grow an RRSP. Eventually, the question changes: how do I turn it into income without paying unnecessary tax? Large withdrawals in a single year can push more income into higher tax brackets and may affect income-tested benefits such as Old Age Security. By December 31 of the year you turn 71, you must deal with your own RRSP by withdrawing it, converting it to a RRIF, purchasing an eligible annuity, or using a permitted combination. RRIFs then have minimum annual withdrawal rules. You don’t need a perfect forecast at 30. As retirement approaches, estimate income, withdrawals, and taxes across several years. Our Canadian retirement calculator can help you explore long-term savings scenarios. Accumulation is only half the plan.

The Outsider Take

These mistakes share a theme: opening an account isn’t the same as having a strategy. The deduction is only one piece. Investments, fees, contribution room, and eventual withdrawals also shape the outcome. If I were reviewing my own RRSP today, I’d start with three questions: What do I own? Why does it belong here? And how will I eventually use this money? You don’t have to get every decision right. But you do need to understand the decisions you’re making.

An RRSP isn’t just about what you put in. It’s about what you keep when you take it out.

Leave a Comment

Scroll to Top